Vintage Homeschooling Advice by Ellenor Fenn, aka "Mrs. Lovechild"

May 25, 2020 | Myrna

With physical classrooms closed and students at home, parents are feeling the pressure to help their children learn. Parenting philosophies have changed over the centuries, but stressing about your child’s education is nothing new. Out of curiosity, I turned to our Osborne Collection of Early Children's Books to explore some vintage homeschooling advice.

Illustration from Cobwebs to Catch Flies (circa 1800).

Travelling back to the 18th century, I looked at the works of education writer Ellenor Fenn. She wrote books designed to ease her readers' homeschooling distress. Centuries before parenting Instagrams or Facebook Groups, mothers turned to Fenn for guidance.

Who was Ellenor Fenn?

Ellenor Frere (birth name) was born in 1744 to a privileged family in Suffolk, England. She did not attend formal schooling and was educated by her aunt. This was common as many upper class 18th-century women were taught at home. In 1766, she married fellow writer John Fenn and settled down in Norfolk, England. She had no biological children but raised two adopted children. Later in life, Fenn became active in the Sunday School movement. This movement sought to teach working class children basic reading, writing and math.

Fenn published under the punny pseudonyms Mrs. Teachwell and Mrs. Lovechild from 1783 until her death in 1813. She was prolific, writing more than 45 books for mothers and children during this period. Some of her most popular works remained in print for more than 50 years after her death. We have 20+ digitized editions of her work, as well as more non-digitized items.

Eighteenth and 19th-century mothers found value in Fenn’s words, but how do her works hold up for modern readers? Fenn's advice is a mix of 18th-century values and progressive ideas. Reading her books shows how education and parenting has changed, but also stayed the same.

Make learning a game

Black and white illustration entitled "The Useful Play" depicting two girls playing at a table.

Illustration from Cobwebs to Catch Flies (circa 1800) showing two girls engaged in "useful play."

Fenn was an early advocate for using play and games to teach young children. Nowadays, we talk about play-based learning for kindergartners. Her 18th-century books focus on the value of "teaching in sport." In The Art of Teaching in Sport, she says that toys can "serve to convey instruction" allowing "precious hours of childhood...improved to good purpose." She recommends using "lively" games to teach children spelling, math and sciences. Fenn suggests that home educators should make learning engaging and match it to the attention span of their child.

Fenn’s books assume that mothers fill the role of home educator. They encourage women to be "mistress of the revels among her little people." In her books, male educators are school masters, not fathers. In the 21st century, women continue to take on more caregiving work than their male counterparts. The pandemic has even increased that workload for many mothers.

Follow your child's curiosity

Black and white illustrations of insects

Illustration from The Rational Dame (circa 1790) showing insects that might be of interest to children.

Memorization and repetition were popular methods of education in the 18th century. Fenn’s books discuss those methods, but also encourage mothers to follow their child’s natural curiosity. The Rational Dame encourages mothers to "[t]alk to a child of an object which has caught his attention, and fear not, he will 'With greedy ear devour up your discourse.'" Her books recommend using outdoor walks as a learning opportunity. Garden walks can help teach biology, geography and other subjects. During this pandemic, parents are using neighbourhood walks to engage their children. Some are setting up local scavenger hunts and encouraging outdoor exploration.

Learn with your child

Black and white illustration of an 18th century woman and child in a garden.

Illustration from Cobwebs to Catch Flies (circa 1800) featuring a mother and child discussing a bird.

In 2020, math is a major source of stress for many families. Methods for teaching basic math concepts have changed, leading to confused homework help sessions. In 18th-century England, it was grammar which caused upper class mothers distress.

In Parsing Lessons for Young Children, Fenn says "[l]adies view [grammar] as arduous undertaking and are fearful of engaging in it." English grammar used to be an afterthought, with Latin grammar prioritized by educators. Latin learning and grammar were usually reserved for men, with privileged boys studying it at school. Many women would not have studied English or Latin grammar at home or school.

In the late 18th century, English grammar received more attention and mothers were now expected to teach it at home. Fenn tried to assist these newly-minted grammar teachers with their homeschooling efforts. Two of Fenn’s most popular books were The Child’s Grammar: Designed to Enable Ladies who may not have Attended to the Subject Themselves to Instruct their Children and The Mother’s Grammar. The books offer lessons plans and explanations which allow teacher and student to learn together.